Moody's Investors Service has lowered the United States' credit rating from its pristine AAA status to Aa1, exacerbating concerns over the nation's ballooning fiscal burden, which has reached historic proportions. While securities analysts largely agree that this downgrade will present headwinds for the stock market, opinions diverge regarding the potential magnitude and duration of the impact.
The Wall Street Journal reported on Saturday that Moody's decision to downgrade the US credit rating reflects the increasing pressure on the US Treasury market, already grappling with escalating debt levels and persistent inflation. This action marks the third instance of a major global credit rating agency stripping the US of its top-tier rating, following Standard & Poor's (S&P) downgrade in 2011 and Fitch Ratings' similar move in 2023. This trifecta of downgrades is fueling anxieties surrounding US Treasury bonds, traditionally considered a safe-haven asset alongside gold.
Growing unease about the creditworthiness of US debt could lead to decreased demand for Treasury bonds, compelling investors to demand higher yields as compensation for the perceived increased risk. This, in turn, would inflate the US federal government's interest expenditures.
As of the 2024 fiscal year, US national debt stood at a record $35.46 trillion. According to the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, interest payments on this debt during the same period amounted to $881 billion, surpassing the annual defense budget of $855 billion. Data compiled up to April of the current 2025 fiscal year indicates interest outlays of $579 billion, suggesting that the total interest burden for this year is on track to significantly exceed the previous year's figure. The foundation projects that annual interest payments could reach $1 trillion by 2026.
Yesha Yadav, a professor at Vanderbilt Law School, characterized the downgrade as a confirmation of the "grim outlook for US government debt," stating that it was "not surprising." Nevertheless, Professor Yadav cautioned, "This will send significant shockwaves through already strained markets. It is also a rebuke to policymakers that they urgently need to embark on fiscal reforms if US Treasuries are to retain their risk-free asset status."
The recent credit rating downgrade is anticipated to pose a significant obstacle to the administration's proposed large-scale tax cuts. The previous administration and the Republican party are pushing to extend the 2017 tax law, which primarily benefits corporations and high-income earners. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that extending these provisions could result in a $3.8 trillion reduction in tax revenue over the next decade. Concurrently, there have been calls for increased defense spending and enhanced border security measures, further straining the fiscal landscape.
Fiscal conservatives within the Republican party have voiced their opposition to such budgetary expansions, emphasizing the need for fiscal prudence. Representative French Hill, a key Republican on the House Financial Services Committee, stated that the downgrade "underscores the dire state of our nation’s finances" and affirmed the House Republicans' commitment to "restoring fiscal sanity and addressing the structural drivers of our debt."
The US stock market, which has experienced a recent upward trajectory, is widely expected to undergo a downward correction in response to the news. Max Gokhman, Chief Investment Officer at Franklin Templeton Investment Solutions, suggested in a Bloomberg interview that reduced demand for US Treasuries could translate to decreased demand for the dollar, leading to a depreciation in its value and negatively impacting investor sentiment in US equities.
However, some analysts believe that any market downturn will be temporary and relatively shallow. Dave Mazza, CEO of Roundhill Investments, argued that "the market was anticipating a downgrade." He contrasted this situation with the 2011 S&P downgrade, asserting that "this downgrade merely reflects existing market concerns about fiscal imbalances and tariff risks, unlike the S&P downgrade which carried a greater element of surprise." Consequently, he anticipates a "relatively muted impact on stock prices."
Kim Forrest, Chief Investment Officer at Bokeh Capital Partners, noted that "this is not the first time the US has been downgraded." She acknowledged potential volatility in futures markets but suggested a wait-and-see approach, stating, "This is not new information for sophisticated investors."
The implications of this downgrade extend beyond the immediate market reaction. Higher borrowing costs for the US government could lead to increased pressure on policymakers to address the nation's fiscal challenges. Potential measures could include spending cuts, tax increases, or a combination of both. However, implementing such measures, particularly in a politically divided environment, could prove to be a significant hurdle.
Furthermore, the downgrade could have broader international ramifications. The perceived weakening of the US creditworthiness might prompt some investors and central banks to re-evaluate their holdings of US Treasury bonds, potentially leading to a gradual diversification of global reserve assets. While the US dollar's status as the world's dominant reserve currency is not expected to change overnight, this development could introduce further volatility into global financial markets.
The timing of the downgrade, amidst ongoing economic uncertainties and geopolitical tensions, adds another layer of complexity to the situation. The Federal Reserve's efforts to combat inflation through interest rate hikes are already weighing on economic growth, and increased borrowing costs for the government could further dampen economic activity.
In conclusion, Moody's decision to lower the US credit rating serves as a stark reminder of the growing fiscal challenges facing the nation. While the immediate impact on financial markets remains uncertain, the long-term implications for government borrowing costs, investor confidence, and the global financial landscape warrant close attention. The downgrade underscores the urgent need for policymakers to forge a consensus on sustainable fiscal policies to ensure the long-term economic stability of the United States.
[Copyright (c) Global Economic Times. All Rights Reserved.]
