
A landmark appellate court decision halting the Saemangeum International Airport project has cast a shadow over South Korea’s broader aviation infrastructure plans, potentially stalling several other regional airports currently in the pipeline.
On November 18, the Seoul High Court upheld a lower court's decision to nullify the government’s master plan for the Saemangeum airport. The court ruled that authorities acted unlawfully by failing to evaluate bird strike hazards during the initial site selection phase. Rejecting the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport’s (MOLIT) argument that wildlife risks are meant to be assessed later in the development process, the bench emphasized that candidate locations must be compared for avian hazards from the outset.
A Systemic Vulnerability Across Projects
The ruling exposes a widespread vulnerability across South Korea's 6th Comprehensive Airport Development Plan (2021–2025), which encompasses eight regional projects. Aside from Saemangeum and Ulleung Airport—currently under construction for a 2028 opening—six other initiatives are in pre-construction stages. These include projects in Gadeokdo and Daegu-Gyeongbuk awaiting groundbreaking, feasibility reviews for Heuksan, Baengnyeong, and Seosan, and public consultations for a second airport on Jeju Island.
Following the fatal Jeju Air crash at Muan Airport two years ago, aviation safety and bird strike prevention have become critical national concerns. A MOLIT official acknowledged that Saemangeum's planning process was no different from other proposed airports, noting that several sites, including Gadeokdo and Jeju, are situated near major migratory bird habitats.
Immediate Legal and Political Ripple Effects
The Gadeokdo New Airport faces the most immediate legal threat. A lawsuit filed by over 1,000 citizens seeking to cancel its master plan is set for its final hearing next month. Because Gadeokdo’s location was expedited via a 2021 special act, it bypassed standard comparative site reviews, evaluating bird strike risks solely against nearby Gimhae Airport. Legal experts suggest the Saemangeum precedent will heavily influence whether courts view these omitted early assessments as fatal legal flaws.
Meanwhile, the ruling is expected to fuel local opposition to the Jeju Second Airport ahead of a planned provincial referendum early next year. Environmental advocates point to government surveys identifying Jeju's eastern coast—the proposed airport site—as the country's top wintering ground for migratory birds, arguing that mitigating collision risks there is virtually impossible.
Furthermore, the court noted that joint safety and ecology guidelines issued by the transport and environment ministries last December merely reaffirmed existing legal and international obligations, meaning stricter standards could retroactively impact ongoing projects.
A Shift in Judicial Oversight
Legal scholars view the ruling as a significant shift in South Korean administrative law. Historically, courts have been reluctant to halt large-scale state-led infrastructure projects, such as the Four Major Rivers Project, deferring to government discretion.
However, observers note that judicial standards regarding environmental protection and public safety have evolved substantially over the past two decades. With the transport ministry preparing to address the ruling at an upcoming public hearing for its 7th Comprehensive Airport Development Plan, legal experts believe the government will face an uphill battle if it chooses to appeal the decision to the Supreme Court.
[Copyright (c) Global Economic Times. All Rights Reserved.]




























