The recently introduced parking fee policy in the city of Encarnación, Paraguay, is facing strong opposition from citizens, merchants, and civic groups, with a growing chorus of demands for its suspension.
Last Monday, the group ‘Self-Convened Citizens (Ciudadanos Autoconvocados)’ submitted an official letter to the Encarnación City Hall through their legal representative, Rogelio Ríos, urging the immediate suspension of the parking fee policy. The letter was accompanied by the signatures of over 4,500 citizens, clearly demonstrating the widespread public opposition to the policy.
Spearheaded by the current Mayor of Encarnación, Luis Yd, the parking fee policy charges drivers who park their vehicles in specific areas of the city. It has sparked significant discontent among local residents, as well as merchants, tourists, and social organizations, right from its initial implementation.
In fact, numerous citizen protests demanding the withdrawal of the policy have taken place in front of the Encarnación City Hall over the past few weeks. Citizens are strongly protesting against the increased economic burden caused by the sudden imposition of fees, as well as the lack of citizen participation in the policy-making process and the problems with the poor public transportation system and urban infrastructure.
Tony Báez, Vice President of the Citizen Comptroller's Office in Encarnación (Contraloría Ciudadana en Encarnación), stated in an interview with a local radio station, "The community already rejected this proposal two years ago, and its implementation was able to be postponed until today," suggesting that similar discussions had occurred in the past. He criticized, "In a situation where the parking fee imposition could create more problems rather than solve them, the basic conditions that should logically be in place before charging fees have not been met."
One of the main issues citizens have with the parking fee policy is the lack of communication and public discussion in the decision-making process. Citizens argue that sufficient information was not provided regarding this important matter, and that a proper process for public debate or consultation was not carried out.
Furthermore, it is pointed out that the sudden imposition of fees, without an efficient and convenient public transportation system in place as an alternative, further hinders the mobility of citizens. Additionally, the poor road conditions and lack of parking spaces in Encarnación, among other urban infrastructure problems, also weaken the legitimacy of the parking fee implementation. Citizens are voicing their opinion that it is unfair to simply charge fees without resolving these fundamental issues.
Encarnación is an important city located in southeastern Paraguay, boasting beautiful natural scenery and a rich cultural heritage, attracting many tourists. In particular, the Costanera, a promenade along the Paraná River, is a major tourist attraction that bustles with citizens and tourists on weekends. In this context, there are concerns that the sudden parking fee imposition could negatively impact the local economy. Merchants are appealing that parking fees will reduce customer visits, which will in turn lead to decreased sales.
Moreover, doubts are being raised about the transparency of the parking fee imposition method and the collection process. There is a lack of clear explanation or safeguards regarding how the collected fees will be used and potential problems that may arise during the fee collection process. Citizens suspect that the purpose of the fee collection is solely to secure tax revenue and are demanding that the collected fees be used transparently for the improvement of urban infrastructure or the expansion of the public transportation system to enhance citizen convenience.
As such, the parking fee policy in Encarnación is facing widespread public opposition and causing significant social conflict. The official request for suspension by the ‘Self-Convened Citizens’ group and the signatures of over 4,500 citizens clearly demonstrate this opposition. The Encarnación city authorities should listen to the voices of these citizens, reconsider the policy implementation, and seek reasonable solutions through sufficient communication and public discussion.
If the city authorities ignore the demands of the citizens and unilaterally push ahead with the policy, the resistance of the citizens will intensify, which could lead to further chaos and deepening conflict throughout the city. The parking fee policy controversy in Encarnación is not just a matter of a single urban policy but will remain a case that once again emphasizes the importance of citizen participation and communication.
[Copyright (c) Global Economic Times. All Rights Reserved.]
