Asunción, Paraguay – In Paraguay, the minimum wage is periodically adjusted based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI). While the CPI is a metric that measures changes in the cost of living, behind this seemingly technical and neutral formula lies a harsh reality. This method fails to prevent the loss of purchasing power for workers and does not reflect the existence of economic inequality. Although intended to compensate for inflation, its design and socioeconomic context are merely temporary measures, far from sufficient to maintain purchasing power.
Rising Cost of Living Exposes Minimum Wage Limitations
The CPI calculates the average increase in the prices of a basic basket of necessities but does not account for the specific expenditure patterns of working-class households. For several years, the prices of items that most significantly affect working-class households, such as food, transportation, and basic services, have tended to rise above the average.
For instance, according to the Central Bank's announcement for the first quarter of this year, fruit and vegetable prices surged by 27.9%. This figure is significantly higher than the price increases for other goods and services that make up the CPI food basket. Such wage adjustments are disconnected from the inflation workers actually face, perpetuating a vicious cycle of increasing household debt and reduced consumption.
From 2019, the annual rate of food price inflation has consistently been higher than the overall average inflation rate. This has resulted in a systematic erosion of income purchasing power due to price increases in items essential for quality of life and public health.
New Attempts to Accurately Reflect Consumption Patterns
Facing criticism regarding the calculation of inflation rates, the Paraguayan government has acknowledged its limitations and the impact on minimum wage adjustments. Consequently, it has expressed its intention to create a new consumption basket that more accurately reflects consumption patterns.
The first challenge for this initiative is to conduct a new survey, which is likely to take place in the second half of this year. Previous surveys were outdated, not only in terms of sample size but also in other factors such as the types of goods and services included. As demographics and consumption patterns change over time, the consumption basket loses its validity, underscoring the importance of periodic updates.
Worsening Inequality: A Key Challenge in Minimum Wage Discussions
Beyond these issues, inequality must be considered. Paraguay is one of the most unequal countries in the region, necessitating a differentiated consideration of the consumption basket. The consumption basket of the lowest quintile of income, where impoverished households are concentrated, differs significantly from that of the highest quintile. Even the top quintile is already skewed, as it includes the wealthiest 3%, whose consumption levels and types differ not only from other quintiles but also from the rest of the highest quintile.
Inflation is fundamental data in economic policy. Despite Paraguay being a food-producing country, one of the items that most significantly impacts the CPI is food. Given that the inflation problem is not merely monetary but a real issue, economic policies and sectoral policies like agriculture cannot overlook the inflation problem. Paraguay not only fails to produce enough food but is increasingly relying on other countries for food supply, wasting foreign currency.
Minimum Wage: Beyond Survival to Guarantee Quality of Life
The CPI indicator conceals a cruel reality: it fails to prevent workers from losing purchasing power and does not reflect the existence of economic inequality. The minimum wage is already merely sufficient to ensure the minimum consumption of working-class households, and if its real value is lost, it becomes entirely insufficient to guarantee a quality of life. The least the government can do is ensure that the minimum wage achieves its goal of covering the basic basket of necessities and that this basket does not lose value over time.
The Complex Relationship Between Paraguay's Economy and Minimum Wage
Paraguay is a landlocked country in South America, with the agricultural sector accounting for a significant portion of its economy. Exports of agricultural and livestock products such as soybeans, corn, and beef are major sources of foreign currency. However, despite this agricultural production, a paradoxical situation is occurring where food prices are driving domestic inflation. This is interpreted as a complex result of fluctuations in international market prices, instability in domestic production, and problems in the distribution structure. In particular, as natural disasters due to climate change become more frequent, the volatility of agricultural production increases, leading to rising food prices and making life even more difficult for vulnerable groups.
Paraguay's minimum wage is typically adjusted annually in July, based on the Central Bank's CPI data. The minimum wage effective from July 1, 2024, is 2,680,373 Paraguayan Guaraní (PYG), which is approximately $355 USD per month. This is an increase of about 5.1% compared to 2023, but as the article points out, it often fails to keep pace with the actual perceived inflation rate, especially food price inflation. This weakens the real purchasing power of low-income individuals and exacerbates difficulties in maintaining a basic standard of living.
Deepening Social Inequality and the Role of the Minimum Wage
Paraguay is considered one of the countries with the most severe income inequality in Latin America. As the concentration of wealth intensifies, a small number of wealthy individuals own most of the assets, and the majority of the working class lives on low incomes, creating a solidified structure. This inequality also creates disparities in access to social services such as education, healthcare, and housing, leading to a deepening cycle of poverty.
The minimum wage is inherently supposed to act as a social safety net, ensuring a minimum income so that workers can live a dignified life. However, in Paraguay's case, concerns are being raised that the current minimum wage adjustment method makes it difficult to fulfill this role properly. There is growing demand to focus not merely on nominally increasing the amount in line with inflation, but on guaranteeing purchasing power for a substantial improvement in the quality of life.
To achieve this, it is essential to develop a new price index that accurately reflects the actual consumption patterns of working-class households, rather than simply chasing CPI figures. Furthermore, a multidimensional approach is needed that considers different consumption structures and price pressures by income quintile. For example, indicators that specifically reflect the price trends of essential food items and daily necessities primarily consumed by low-income groups should be introduced, or additional social support measures should be explored to increase their purchasing power.
Policy Recommendations and Future Challenges
The Paraguayan government's effort to improve data accuracy through a new consumption basket survey is positive. However, it should not stop there, and the following additional policy efforts are needed:
CPI Index Reform: The method for calculating the CPI should be improved to accurately reflect the consumption patterns of low-income groups and to ensure that price changes in essential goods like food have a greater impact on the minimum wage.
Improved Wage Negotiation Structure: Rather than solely relying on technical indicators for minimum wage decisions, there is a need to discuss the introduction of a Living Wage concept through social dialogue involving labor, employers, and the government.
Agricultural and Food Policy Reform: Leveraging its advantage as a food-producing country, Paraguay should increase domestic food self-sufficiency and streamline distribution channels to stabilize agricultural product prices. This will contribute to increasing the real purchasing power of the minimum wage.
Strengthening Social Safety Nets: Expand subsidies and social service support for the impoverished, such as housing, education, and healthcare, which cannot be solved by the minimum wage alone, to improve the overall quality of life.
Policies to Address Inequality: Actively pursue income redistribution policies, such as strengthening progressive taxation and introducing wealth taxes, to alleviate socioeconomic inequality.
The minimum wage is not just a number; it is a crucial indicator of whether a country's workers can live with minimal dignity. The Paraguayan government must seize this opportunity to explore fundamental changes so that the minimum wage can truly guarantee the quality of life for its citizens, not just be a tool for survival. If these efforts succeed, Paraguay will be able to move towards a more just and sustainable society.
[Copyright (c) Global Economic Times. All Rights Reserved.]
