(C) Kamisetas.com

SEOUL—In a major blow to brand trust, The North Face, operated by Youngone Outdoor, has been forced to issue full refunds for 13 different down jacket and vest models after admitting that the filling material composition was incorrectly labelled. What many consumers believed to be premium goose down was, in reality, recycled down, sparking widespread consumer complaints and a scramble by the brand to rectify the situation.

The controversy first surfaced after a customer inquiry regarding the '1996 Retro Nuptse Jacket' sold on the e-commerce platform Musinsa. Consumers had purchased the jacket under the impression that the filling consisted of 80% goose down and 20% goose feathers. However, a subsequent review and inspection confirmed that the actual material used was recycled down.

Musinsa was the first to announce a refund policy on December 2nd, stating that the mislabelling was a result of an outside sales agency failing to properly update product information when new seasonal items were released. This negligence meant the incorrect filler blend from a previous iteration was retained, misleading buyers.

Premium Perception Vs. Reality

The issue quickly escalated due to the significant difference in perceived value and quality between the materials. Down, the soft cluster of fibers taken from the underbellies of ducks or geese, is prized for its superior insulation properties. Goose down (구스다운, guseudaun) is generally considered a "premium material," offering better warmth than duck down (덕다운, deokdaun). Therefore, the incorrect classification as goose down when recycled down was used constitutes a serious breach of consumer trust. Recycled down, while being an environmentally conscious choice, is not typically marketed or priced as a premium alternative in the same category as virgin goose down.

Following the initial discovery, Youngone Outdoor conducted a full audit of its down products, confirming that a total of 13 product types were affected by similar filler composition errors. On December 3rd, the operator posted an official notice on The North Face’s website, acknowledging the mislabelling and listing the affected products.

The 13 models subject to the full refund are:

Men's Remaster Down Jacket
Men's Water Shield Nuptse Jacket
1996 Retro Nuptse Vest
1996 Retro Nuptse Jacket
Nuptse Short Jacket
Novelty Nuptse Down Jacket
1996 Nuptse Air Down Jacket
Lofty Down Jacket
Puffy On EX Vest
Cloud Nuptse Down Vest
Arenal Jacket
Sky Down Vest
Novelty Nuptse Down Vest
Conflicting Compensation Claims

In their official statement, The North Face emphasized that they immediately corrected the product information upon discovering the error to prevent further damage. They also announced that customers who purchased the affected items during the period of mislabelling would be individually contacted with details on the full refund procedure.

However, the handling of the compensation plan was marred by initial confusion. An earlier report by Yonhap News TV suggested that The North Face had agreed to provide customers with 100,000 KRW worth of Musinsa points as additional compensation, attributing the error to a "staff mistake." This compensation for damages was notably absent from the final official public notice.

A Youngone Outdoor representative later clarified the discrepancy, stating that the public relations manager had prematurely communicated a non-finalized compensation proposal. The company confirmed that the official announcement made by Musinsa—offering full refunds only—represents the final resolution.

The incident has raised significant concerns about the brand’s quality control and supply chain transparency. With brand credibility at stake, all eyes are now on The North Face and Musinsa to see how they navigate this crisis and work to restore consumer faith in their labelling accuracy and commitment to product integrity. The situation underscores the increasing demand from consumers for verifiable, accurate information regarding the materials used in high-cost apparel, especially premium winter wear.