How Voters and Global Markets Outlasted the Tariff Shock

KO YONG-CHUL Reporter

korocamia@naver.com | 2026-11-23 07:01:00

A midterm rebuke at home and restraint abroad suggest that economic pragmatism is surviving a wave of protectionism.

The sweeping Democratic gains in the recent U.S. midterm elections represent more than a routine shift in congressional power; they serve as a pointed referendum on the economic nationalism of Donald Trump’s second term. Following federal court rulings in February and May that invalidated key pillars of the administration's universal and reciprocal tariff regimes, American voters have delivered a decisive political verdict on policies that strained household budgets and disrupted labor markets.

From the outset, the administration's dual reliance on sweeping import duties and aggressive deportation drives faced broad skepticism from mainstream economists. Because tariffs function primarily as a tax paid by domestic importers and passed along to consumers, the inflationary fallout was largely foreseeable. Similarly, restricting the labor supply through mass removals failed to generate the promised gains in native-born employment or overall economic welfare. The electoral backlash suggests that everyday economic realities ultimately outweighed populist rhetoric at the ballot box.

Crucially, the resilience of the global economy over the past two years owes just as much to restraint outside the United States. When Washington unleashed steep tariff hikes in early 2025, fears mounted that major trading nations would retaliate indiscriminately, triggering a downward spiral reminiscent of the 1930s.

History offered a stark warning. Following the 1929 stock market crash, U.S. tariff increases under President Herbert Hoover prompted defensive measures from Britain—championed by then-Chancellor Neville Chamberlain—and swiftly ignited a global trade war. Between 1929 and 1933, world trade contracted by roughly 65 percent, deepening the Great Depression and destabilizing international order.

In 2025 and 2026, however, the global trading system absorbed the shock without fracturing. While data from the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) shows that U.S. duties—affecting a market representing roughly 13 percent of global imports—nudged average global tariffs up by 1 percentage point on agricultural goods and 2.8 percentage points on manufactured products in 2025, global trade volume still expanded by 8 percent that year. Projections released by the World Trade Organization (WTO) in October indicate that trade growth is holding steady at a similar pace this year, even amid heightened geopolitical conflict in the Middle East.

This divergence from the 1930s reflects a widespread recognition of how deeply modern prosperity depends on cross-border integration—a reality underscored in works like Ben Chu’s Exile Economics, which details how everyday staples from soybeans to steel rely on intricate international supply chains. Rather than replicating Washington’s blanket protectionism, major economies largely confined their responses to targeted countermeasures against the U.S. while keeping trade lanes open with one another. In effect, the world treated American protectionism as an anomaly to be managed rather than a model to be emulated.

To be sure, economic nationalism remains a potent force in American politics. Much as protectionist sentiment persisted during the Biden administration, the broader ideological currents of Trumpism will continue to shape policy debates, making a sudden U.S. return to multilateral pacts like the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) unlikely.

Yet the past two years have demonstrated the limits of unilateral economic disruption. By rejecting a contagious trade war abroad and registering discontent at home, both global markets and American voters have signaled a preference for pragmatic interdependence over isolation.

[ⓒ Global Economic Times. 무단전재-재배포 금지]

WEEKLY HOT