Supreme Court En Banc Overturns and Remands Former PM Han Duck-soo’s Case on Grounds of Partial Acquittal
KO YONG-CHUL Reporter
korocamia@naver.com | 2026-11-19 18:18:34
The Supreme Court’s en banc panel (presided over by Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae) overturned and remanded the lower court’s ruling that had sentenced former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo to 15 years in prison on charges of engaging in key duties of an insurrection.
While the en banc panel ruled that the December 3 declaration of martial law constituted an insurrection, it found it difficult to recognize the "purpose of subverting the Constitution"—a statutory requirement for the crime of insurrection—regarding some of the charges against Han.
En Banc Panel: “Dec. 3 Martial Law Was Unconstitutional and Illegal in Itself”
The en banc panel deemed the December 3 martial law unconstitutional and illegal in its own right. The Supreme Court stated, "The declaration of martial law in this case—proclaimed with the intent to mobilize the military and police to seize control of the National Assembly and media outlets without substantively undergoing deliberation by the State Council, a mandatory prior procedure under the Constitution—violates the constitutional order and infringes upon the fundamental rights of the people, leaving no doubt as to its inherent unconstitutionality and illegality."
However, the court’s judgment diverged by specific act regarding whether Han possessed the "purpose of subverting the Constitution." The Supreme Court divided Han’s insurrection-related charges into three main categories: (1) creating the appearance of a quorum by convening the State Council prior to the martial law declaration; (2) attempting to secure procedural legitimacy by obtaining signatures on related documents; and (3) discussing cutting off electricity and water to media outlets with former Interior and Safety Minister Lee Sang-min.
Opinions split over whether the "purpose of subverting the Constitution" applied to his recommendation to hold a State Council meeting and the summoning of its members. Regarding the post-declaration countersignature and the discussions on cutting off power and water, the justices unanimously agreed that the charge of engaging in key duties of an insurrection was established.
Majority Opinion: “Difficult to Recognize Intent to Participate in Insurrection by Convening State Council”
Regarding Han’s recommendation for State Council deliberation, the majority opinion stated that "circumstances exist that make it difficult to conclude he had the intent to participate in an insurrection." This implies that Han’s claim—that he convened the State Council in an attempt to dissuade the declaration of martial law—cannot be entirely dismissed.
Rather, the court noted that "Han can be seen as having directly or indirectly expressed a stance opposing martial law, albeit moderately." It cited cabinet members' testimonies that Han told former Deputy Prime Minister for Economic Affairs Choi Sang-mok, "I have already spoken against it several times," and "Go inside and try to dissuade him." The court also noted that convening the meeting actually delayed the declaration, during which time Choi and former Foreign Minister Cho Tae-yul voiced their opposition.
The majority further pointed out that finding the act of convening a State Council meeting guilty could set a harmful behavioral precedent, signaling to future officials that they should avoid recommending State Council deliberation in order to evade liability for insurrection.
However, the court found him guilty regarding the post-declaration countersigning of the martial law proclamation and the discussions on cutting off electricity and water. The Supreme Court explained, "Once martial law is declared, the possibility of reversing or prompting reconsideration of Yoon Suk Yeol’s decision virtually disappears, and the question of whether to participate in the unfolding situation comes to the forefront," adding that "the circumstances before and after the declaration differ, and the criminal law evaluation of intent may also differ accordingly." The court also upheld guilty verdicts for countersigning the proclamation after the fact to conceal procedural defects (falsification of official documents) and subsequently destroying it (violation of the Presidential Records Management Act and destruction of public documents).
Minority Opinion: “The Three Acts Constitute a Continuous Series of Actions”
Three justices (Oh Kyung-mi, Shin Sook-hee, and Kim Seong-su) issued a dissenting opinion. They argued, "In a presidential self-coup, the destruction of the constitutional order takes the outward appearance of official administrative acts; therefore, the fact that the Prime Minister’s actions 'followed legally prescribed procedures' cannot serve as a meaningful criterion to distinguish 'participation in insurrection and the purpose of subverting the Constitution.'"
The minority opinion stated, "Even though it was inevitable that a hollowed-out State Council meeting would end up backing the legitimacy of the insurrectionary act, the defendant chose the active measure of recommending the meeting." They added, "It is difficult to accept the majority opinion’s recognition of the purpose of subverting the Constitution for acts after the declaration while denying it for acts prior to the declaration," asserting that the three charges form a continuous series of actions.
First Supreme Court Ruling Establishing Insurrection for the Dec. 3 Martial Law
This ruling marks the Supreme Court’s first determination on whether the December 3 martial law constitutes an insurrection. The decision is expected to serve as a benchmark for the upcoming appellate ruling on former President Yoon Suk Yeol, who is charged as the ringleader of the insurrection. Military and police leaders, including former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun and former National Police Agency Commissioner General Cho Ji-ho, have also been indicted for engaging in key insurrection duties and are awaiting their appellate verdicts alongside Yoon. Meanwhile, the cases of former Justice Minister Park Sung-jae and former Interior Minister Lee Sang-min—who were each sentenced to nine years in prison by the appellate court—are currently pending before the Supreme Court.
Although Han’s detention period for the final appeal was originally set to expire on November 20, the Supreme Court decided on the same day to renew his detention.
[ⓒ Global Economic Times. 무단전재-재배포 금지]
WEEKLY HOT
- 1AI Giant Anthropic Hits $2 Trillion Valuation in Record-Breaking Nasdaq Debut Before Pulling Back
- 2South Korean Universities Tighten Exam Rules to Curb AI Cheating, Sparking Last-Minute Confusion
- 3From Kitchen Staples to Metabolic Tools: Why Science Is Vindicating Vinegar and Animal Fats
- 4Tragic Death of Top Law Exam Scorer Exposes Cracks in South Korea’s ‘Test-Obsessed’ Culture in the AI Era
- 5Chungbuk Bio Industry-University Convergence Institute Supports Cheongju Medical Device Companies’ Entry into the German Market
- 6Gangwon Tourism Organization Goes All-Out to Attract Cruise Calls to Sokcho Port at Seatrade Cruise Asia 2026