Federal Judge Allows DRAM Price-Fixing Lawsuit Against Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron to Proceed
Nathan Ko Special Correspondent
konathansang@gmail | 2026-11-16 11:47:26
SAN FRANCISCO — A U.S. federal judge has cleared the way for a high-stakes antitrust lawsuit to move forward, refusing to throw out allegations that the world's three largest memory chip makers conspired to squeeze general-purpose DRAM supplies and artificially inflate prices.
The ruling, handed down by Judge Noel Wise of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, targets Samsung Electronics, SK Hynix, and Micron Technology. The court determined that the plaintiffs presented sufficient evidence to make their claims of market manipulation plausible, setting up a rigorous legal showdown over how the chip giants managed their production shifts.
The litigation stems from a complaint filed last June by a group of 17 U.S. consumers and small business owners. Operating as indirect purchasers of personal computers, laptops, and other hardware components, the plaintiffs accuse the trio of memory leaders—who commanded over 91% of the global DRAM market as of the third quarter of 2025—of orchestrating coordinated production slowdowns that sent prices skyrocketing by nearly 700% over an 18-month span.
At the heart of the dispute is a fundamental disagreement over corporate strategy: whether the memory makers independently pivoted away from legacy general-purpose DRAM toward lucrative High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) to chase AI demand, or if they acted in concert to restrict supply.
Plaintiffs pointed to a series of coordinated-looking actions, including rolling production cuts starting in late 2022, synchronized rollbacks of DDR4 manufacturing capacity in mid-2025, and Micron's sunsetting of its Crucial consumer brand. They also highlighted joint refusals to sign long-term supply agreements for standard DRAM while locking in long-term contracts for AI customers, alongside remarkably similar customer-screening questionnaires deployed in January.
The tech companies pushed back, arguing the lawsuit is a recycled version of previously dismissed litigation. They maintained that their business adjustments were independent reactions to market volatility and surging AI hardware needs, describing their competitive vigilance as watching each other "like hawks."
Judge Wise, however, was unpersuaded by that defense. In her ruling, she remarked that the manufacturers' parallel behavior looked less like passive observation and "closer to hawks flying in formation." The court emphasized that the defendants failed to adequately explain their rapid, simultaneous exits from the DDR4 market, noting that identical customer-vetting questions further bolstered the plausibility of a conspiracy.
Still, the court trimmed parts of the complaint, dismissing arguments tied to older DDR3 chips, investor remarks, and casual industry conference interactions due to insufficient backing.
The decision is strictly procedural, meaning the court has not yet made a final determination on liability or proven actual collusion. The defendants are required to submit their formal answers by December 7, with an initial case management conference slated for January 12.
[ⓒ Global Economic Times. 무단전재-재배포 금지]
WEEKLY HOT
- 1Ministry of SMEs and Startups Kicks Off Regional Preliminaries for "Everyone's Startup" Local Track
- 292% of SMEs Say, "Foreign Workers Must Work at Their First Workplace for 3 Years or More"
- 3Accommodation Cancellations Unilateral Like During BTS Concert Prohibited… 200% Total Fee Compensation
- 4Ruling Party Deepens Internal Divisions Over Senior Member’s Impeachment Comments Amid Mounting Economic Challenges
- 5Powering the AI Boom: Who Should Foot the Grid Bill?
- 6AI-Driven Cheating in the Age of Artificial Intelligence: Safeguarding the College Scholastic Ability Test (CSAT)