Trump Administration Defies Court Orders on Immigration, Escalating Judicial Clash

Sharon Yoon Correspondent

sharoncho0219@gmail.com | 2025-03-20 11:12:45

Washington D.C. – The Trump administration is intensifying its confrontation with the judicial branch, refusing to comply with court orders regarding immigration deportations. The Justice Department has rejected a federal judge's request for information about flights deporting immigrants to El Salvador, asserting that the judiciary is overstepping its bounds.

Judge James Boasberg of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia requested details about a flight that deported Venezuelan nationals to El Salvador, including takeoff and landing times and the number of deportees. The Justice Department declined to provide the information, arguing that it constitutes a "serious intrusion on the absolute and unreviewable executive powers related to national security, foreign relations, and foreign policy." They also indicated that some of the requested information may involve "national secrets."

According to the Associated Press, the Justice Department's filing stated, "The premise of these orders is that the judiciary is superior to the executive branch. The government disagrees. The judicial and executive branches are equal, and the judicial branch's continued encroachment on the executive's prerogatives, particularly on non-legal and factually irrelevant matters, must end."

Judge Boasberg responded by ordering the Justice Department to either provide the flight information or formally declare that it cannot be disclosed due to "national security" concerns. He also questioned the validity of the "national security" argument, noting that the government had already released some details about the flights.

This dispute follows Judge Boasberg's earlier order to halt the Trump administration's deportation of hundreds of Venezuelan nationals, designated as members of the "Tren de Aragua" cartel, to El Salvador. He further ordered that any deported individuals be returned to the United States, even if the deportation flights had already departed. The Trump administration disregarded this order, proceeding with the deportations.

President Trump subsequently called for Judge Boasberg's impeachment, prompting a rare public statement from Chief Justice John Roberts, who rebuked the impeachment suggestion.

White House spokesperson Caroline Levitt stated that while no specific deportation flights to El Salvador were currently planned, the administration would continue "mass deportations." She also addressed the escalating conflict with the judiciary, stating, "The president has made it clear that judges need to be impeached, and he has also expressed great respect for Chief Justice Roberts. The president believes that the Supreme Court has a responsibility to control these activist judges."

Levitt further accused Judge Boasberg of being a "Democrat activist," citing his appointment by former President Barack Obama and his wife's donations to the Democratic Party. She argued that Judge Boasberg was "attempting to say that the president does not have the executive authority to deport foreign terrorists from U.S. soil. This is a severe abuse of power by the judge."

While asserting that the administration would "continue to comply with court orders," Levitt also stated that the White House counsel and the Justice Department were "studying this issue and will appeal. We will use all of our resources, and we know that we will win, even if we have to go to the Supreme Court."

WEEKLY HOT